How to draw Secret Santa names fairly
In Secret Santa (Wichteln in German) everyone gives a gift to exactly one person, and nobody knows who their own gift comes from. The draw is the delicate part: nobody may draw themselves, and nobody should know all the pairs.
To avoid a wrong expectation: Festrunde does not draw Secret Santa names at present. The methods below need no software. What Festrunde is still useful for is described at the end.
Rules to settle beforehand
- Budget: a fixed amount or a narrow range, for example 10 to 15 euros.
- Dates: when the draw is done and when the gifts are handed over.
- Type: classic Secret Santa, a white elephant swap with things from home, or a version with dice and swapping.
- Wish notes: yes or no. Two or three keywords per person help a lot, especially among colleagues.
- Secrecy: is it revealed at the end who had whom?
- Wrapping: no sender, but the recipient's name on the outside.
Method 1: Drawing slips when everyone is together
- Everyone writes their name on a slip of the same size and folds it twice.
- All slips go into a bowl.
- People draw in turn. Anyone who draws their own name says so at once, puts the slip back and draws again.
- If the last person draws their own name, all slips go back and the round starts again. That is the only way it stays secret.
The advantage is that everyone can see the draw is fair.
Method 2: A neutral person does the draw
When not everyone is in the same place, someone who is not taking part does it: a partner, a colleague from another department, the grandparents.
- The neutral person writes all names on slips and shuffles them.
- They lay the slips out in a row. Everyone gives to the person on their right, and the last gives to the first.
- They send each participant a private message with the name of the person they are buying for.
Because of the row, nobody can get themselves, and no two people end up giving to each other. The neutral person does know all the pairs, though, and has to be able to keep quiet.
Method 3: Envelopes when people come by one at a time
In an office, a daycare or a club, people are rarely all there at once.
- One person prepares sealed, identical envelopes with one name in each.
- The envelopes sit in a box in a fixed place.
- Everyone takes one when they come by. Anyone who draws themselves reseals the envelope, puts it back and draws again.
As with method 1: if only your own name is left at the end, swap unopened with someone who has not bought anything yet.
And online?
There are Secret Santa generators on the web that draw names and send each person the result by link or email. If you use one, check first what data it asks for. First names are enough for a draw. Only enter other people's email addresses if they agree.
Common mishaps
- Someone drops out after the draw. Agree that this person tells the organiser who they had, and the organiser reassigns that name.
- The budget is read very differently. A narrow range is better than "around 10 euros".
- Someone ends up with nothing. A neutral spare gift kept by the organiser saves the evening.
- Couples draw each other. If you want to rule that out, method 2 suits best, because the neutral person can arrange the row accordingly.
- Gifts cannot be matched to people. The recipient's name belongs on the outside of the parcel.
Checklist for the Secret Santa party
- Fix the date and place, collect replies
- Put the budget and rules in the invitation
- Do the draw at least two weeks before the party
- A table or a sack for the gifts
- Biscuits, punch or tea, mugs
- Dice, if you are swapping
- One spare gift
What Festrunde can take care of
The date, the replies and the list of who brings biscuits, punch or mugs. The budget and rules fit in the note on the invitation. Festrunde's secret gift list is meant for a single recipient, such as a birthday child, and does not replace a draw.
Related guide: How to organise a potluck.